The God of the Gaps: a parable

I’ve just read a post called Dear Christians at The Indigestible (seen first at God is for Suckers). While the post is itself interesting, in my opinion, the best part is a long comment by Abacquer in response to a typical fundamentalist trollish comment, which is perhaps the best refutation of the “god of the gaps” fallacy I’ve ever seen.

It starts like this:

Imagine there is a giant boulder sitting on top of a high hill. One rainy and windy day, the boulder’s purchase is so eroded that it finally tumbles down the hill scouring a huge groove in the surface of the hill. The way down is rocky and clogged with debris, so the boulder, as it tumbles, bounces this way and that, popping up in the air when it hits an outcrop or a fallen tree. At the bottom of the hill, the boulder bounces off the ground and falls into the lake beyond, where it sinks into the mud and is covered over by water.

Hundreds of years later some men come by and notice the great furrow cut in the surface of the hill. The furrow is incomplete because over time parts of it have weathered away, and a subsequent landslide has destroyed portions of it, and there were times when the boulder was airborne. The rock itself lay hidden beneath the muddy floor of the lake. The men try to explain what caused this furrow. One man, the theist, says that God created the furrow. The other men like this idea and they go back to their village and spread the good word, culminating in Fred Franklin writing a book that tells about God creating the furrow.

And the best is yet to come. :) Go on, read it.

Related posts:

  1. Comment deleted by mistake
  2. Revenge of the God of the Gaps
  3. The "God of the Gaps" mentality
  4. Christianity without the Bible, part 2
  5. Theist and Atheist thought; or The God of the Gaps

2 Responses to “The God of the Gaps: a parable”


  1. 1 Warren

    I thought it was a pretty good one too. I’m glad it got posted there. And here as well! ;)

  2. 2 Kren

    Read it, wonderful.
    Anybody can take head to the points offered there.

Leave a Reply








Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.5 Portugal
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.5 Portugal